Vanessa Thomas SC finds success in the ACT Supreme Court, in ACT v Higgins [2026] ACTCA 38
The ACT Court of Appeal (McCallum CJ, Mossop and Baker JJ) recently handed down its decision in ACT v Higgins [2026] ACTCA 38, allowing an appeal from a decision of McWilliam J. Vanessa Thomas SC, leading John Bird (of the ACT Bar) and Aryan Mohseni (11 Wentworth), appeared for the ACT, which was the lead appellant.
Mrs Higgins owned land in a residential housing estate in Canberra known as Harcourt Hill estate. When the estate was developed in the 1990’s and early 2000’s, it included an 18 hole golf course. Mrs Higgins’ land adjoined the golf course. The Crown Lease over the golf course land, granted by the relevant ACT planning authority, required that the golf course land be used only as an 18 hole golf course. In 2018, the owner of the golf course land (which was also a party to the appeal) publicly canvassed the possibility of seeking planning approval to redevelop some or all the golf course land. In the Court below, Mrs Higgins sought declaratory and other relief that would have the effect that the Territory, and its planning authority, would be precluded from approving any change in the use of the golf course land.
In the Court below, McWilliam J found that the Territory was the “common vendor” of an equitable scheme of development that included the golf course land and Mrs Higgins’ land. On that basis, her Honour granted Mrs Higgins declaratory relief – to the effect that the Territory and its planning authority were obliged to give effect to the covenant in the Crown Lease that restricted the use of the land for the purpose of a golf course. The apparent effect of this declaration would be to prevent the ACT planning authority ever approving a change in the use of the golf course land.
The Territory succeeded in its appeal from this decision. The Court of Appeal concluded that there was no scheme of development enforceable in equity because the evidence did not establish that any of the relevant participants in the contended for scheme, intended that there would be mutually enforceable covenants restricting the use of both the residential blocks in the Harcourt Hill estate and the golf course. The declaratory relief granted by the Court below was set aside.
The case required extensive argument concerning the enforcement of restrictive covenants under the equitable doctrine of schemes of development as well as the Commonwealth and Territory laws governing the system of planning and land management in the ACT.
Link to the judgement can be found here: https://lnkd.in/du7Vy82B
Published: November 16, 2026